Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
Moderator: thunderchero
Forum rules
Please search before starting new topic.
There is a good chance it has already been asked.
Please search before starting new topic.
There is a good chance it has already been asked.
Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
I was wondering (couldn't find anything searching) if anyone had modded/balanced the cloak ability in combat?
In vanilla BOTF cloak seemed to be massively overpowered when dealing with large fleets. I recall a pitched battle with 20-30 ships a side, Romulans vs Federation, of comparable cost, where the Romulans wiped out about 60% of the Federation fleet in its free cloaking turn. I think in large part due to the strike cruisers and their torpedo volleys, which rarely missed such a large target.
I imagine taking away the free combat turn when cloaked, leaving the cloaks ability to just sneaking in fleets and getting a free chance to run away. Still a big advantage in my opinion, and seems more fitting with the TV series. Though I imagine the downside is that the ship stats account for the cloak ability, and would need boosting to compensate.
Any thoughts on this?
In vanilla BOTF cloak seemed to be massively overpowered when dealing with large fleets. I recall a pitched battle with 20-30 ships a side, Romulans vs Federation, of comparable cost, where the Romulans wiped out about 60% of the Federation fleet in its free cloaking turn. I think in large part due to the strike cruisers and their torpedo volleys, which rarely missed such a large target.
I imagine taking away the free combat turn when cloaked, leaving the cloaks ability to just sneaking in fleets and getting a free chance to run away. Still a big advantage in my opinion, and seems more fitting with the TV series. Though I imagine the downside is that the ship stats account for the cloak ability, and would need boosting to compensate.
Any thoughts on this?
- slickrcbd
- Lieutenant-Commander
- Posts: 200
- Joined: Tue Sep 08, 2015 9:22 pm
- Location: in front of a computer
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
The ships stats would definitely need to be improved. There's an annoying thing where the cloak usually gets disengaged after some kind of encounter with the ship, and I've forgotten to check and turn it back on.
Then I get into a fight and without that free shot, I lose even when I have a ship or two advantage. Such as a cruiser, three destroyers and a scout vs an enemy cruiser and two destroyers.
Alternately, I have a regular crew of a cruiser, two destroyers and a scout (all regular) and I lose to a green cruiser and two green destroyers without the cloak played by the AI.
Granted, the scout doesn't give much combat advantage other than giving you intel on the enemy crew experience.
Then I get into a fight and without that free shot, I lose even when I have a ship or two advantage. Such as a cruiser, three destroyers and a scout vs an enemy cruiser and two destroyers.
Alternately, I have a regular crew of a cruiser, two destroyers and a scout (all regular) and I lose to a green cruiser and two green destroyers without the cloak played by the AI.
Granted, the scout doesn't give much combat advantage other than giving you intel on the enemy crew experience.
- thunderchero
- Site Administrator aka Fleet Admiral
- Posts: 7963
- Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2008 2:00 am
- Location: On a three month training mission, in command of the USS Valiant.
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
what if instead it went into normal combat, but you could not target cloaked ships?
but you could hail, evade or retreat. but I doubt AI would take advantage of this....
but you could hail, evade or retreat. but I doubt AI would take advantage of this....
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
Alternatives, cumulative or not:
general
- cloaked ships always have their shields down
combat
- when ships decloak in combat, their shields go down (this is also enforced by the above)
- in their free round, cloaked ships can only fire their disruptors
- in their free round, cloaked ships can only fire their torpedoes
- the first round is free, but in the 2nd round they can't fire (and agility is negated?)
Having their shields down in the first round of combat means that in the 2nd round they'll have some shields, depending on their recharge rate, but they'll be more vulnerable nevertheless.
general
- cloaked ships always have their shields down
combat
- when ships decloak in combat, their shields go down (this is also enforced by the above)
- in their free round, cloaked ships can only fire their disruptors
- in their free round, cloaked ships can only fire their torpedoes
- the first round is free, but in the 2nd round they can't fire (and agility is negated?)
Having their shields down in the first round of combat means that in the 2nd round they'll have some shields, depending on their recharge rate, but they'll be more vulnerable nevertheless.
- thunderchero
- Site Administrator aka Fleet Admiral
- Posts: 7963
- Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2008 2:00 am
- Location: On a three month training mission, in command of the USS Valiant.
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
this might be possible for Supremacy, but not for BOTF.Iceman wrote: ↑Fri Apr 10, 2020 5:37 am Alternatives, cumulative or not:
general
- cloaked ships always have their shields down
combat
- when ships decloak in combat, their shields go down (this is also enforced by the above)
- in their free round, cloaked ships can only fire their disruptors
- in their free round, cloaked ships can only fire their torpedoes
- the first round is free, but in the 2nd round they can't fire (and agility is negated?)
Having their shields down in the first round of combat means that in the 2nd round they'll have some shields, depending on their recharge rate, but they'll be more vulnerable nevertheless.
I have found the code change for my suggestion, but still testing how AI will reacts. so far they just sit and don't move like sitting ducks, but that is the way it was before anyway. so change is only helping human player.
- Spocks-cuddly-tribble
- Code Master
- Posts: 1961
- Joined: Sun Apr 27, 2008 2:00 am
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
Yes, a clear bug, they shouldn't be protected by shields from stellar object damage on the map.
You mean shields 'stay' down, right?
In tactical combat their shields are down in the beginning, but this is hard to notice, since they can't be targeted (unless a fully cloaked fleet attacks a partly cloaked combat-group and the torpedo glitch catches some of the cloaked ships in group).
All pretty intricate to do in BotF primitive asm code, and there is way more interesting unfinished combat features (beam/torpedo vs shields/hull modifier, shield level, pulse weapons....). My idea was always something like only 2 beam shots and only 1 torpedo during surprise attack.
This sounds interesting and might be feasible. Just setting their shields to 1 (or say 12,5 - 50%). But then again, I would just reduce the shield strength in shiplist.sst, instead of messing with the asm code, only to justify a higher shield strength when flying uncloaked.
However, good points Iceman!
[Good thing AFC adopted you as a foundling from the Nile river all those years ago. So after the Random Plagues punished your players, you can lead us across the sea of the Bugged Codes to the Promised Features.]
Strange, I expected it to crash the game, since one must find and re-code tons of tactical combat target code switches (fully cloaked, partly cloaked & many more for monster).thunderchero wrote: ↑Fri Apr 10, 2020 8:16 amI have found the code change for my suggestion, but still testing how AI will reacts. so far they just sit and don't move like sitting ducks, but that is the way it was before anyway. so change is only helping human player.
EDIT: But you might try to remove
Code: Select all
AUTO:00471C3A jnz start_free_cloak_loc
I don't know how many bugs is too many but that point is reached somewhere before however many in BotF is.
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
That'll make Neutron Stars pretty devastating thoughSpocks-cuddly-tribble wrote: ↑Fri Apr 10, 2020 10:00 amYes, a clear bug, they shouldn't be protected by shields from stellar object damage on the map.
Well, like I said above, if the 1st assumption (shields always down) is taken, yes, they should stay down. If not though, during combat they should be "depleted" at the start; not zeroed out because if so, shields will not regenerate, but set to 1 or something. But if that is already the case, nvm Never noticed it TBH.You mean shields 'stay' down, right?
In tactical combat their shields are down in the beginning, but this is hard to notice, since they can't be targeted (unless a fully cloaked fleet attacks a partly cloaked combat-group and the torpedo glitch catches some of the cloaked ships in group).
Yeah. Good thing that Supremacy allows such flexibility What about Plasma Torpedoes (Roms), can't recall if they're working as intended - they are/were supposed to not have a minimum range, IIRC?All pretty intricate to do in BotF primitive asm code, and there is way more interesting unfinished combat features (beam/torpedo vs shields/hull modifier, shield level, pulse weapons....). My idea was always something like only 2 beam shots and only 1 torpedo during surprise attack.
2B+1T, doesn't that make a scout just as effective as a command or a strike? Kind of odd...
Oops, should have read everything better before starting to reply...This sounds interesting and might be feasible. Just setting their shields to 1 (or say 12,5 - 50%). But then again, I would just reduce the shield strength in shiplist.sst, instead of messing with the asm code, only to justify a higher shield strength when flying uncloaked.
You mean simply decrease their shields, period? That will also affect recharging times - just thinking out loud.
Thanks. I think?However, good points Iceman!
[Good thing AFC adopted you as a foundling from the Nile river all those years ago. So after the Random Plagues punished your players, you can lead us across the sea of the Bugged Codes to the Promised Features.]
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
Man, I have so much to do and now you've made me go back to combat and see about implementing some of this stuff in Sup...
Another thought crossed my mind while looking at the Sup combat code. How about firing all weapons, but with no bonuses whatsoever? Crew XP, Computer TL, C&C bonuses, whatever.
Another thought crossed my mind while looking at the Sup combat code. How about firing all weapons, but with no bonuses whatsoever? Crew XP, Computer TL, C&C bonuses, whatever.
- Spocks-cuddly-tribble
- Code Master
- Posts: 1961
- Joined: Sun Apr 27, 2008 2:00 am
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
Yes, but only if they are this turn's destination. Just passing stellar objects doesn't trigger any effect (aside of outposts/starbases can intercept). Another glitch....
Minimum distance to target to fire torpedoes can be modded from 0-x for any ship IIRC, but the whole code is buggy as hell, inter alia with missing/unfinished torpedo launcher hardpoints and different mechanics for ship scale & model radius with different impacts each.
Not entirely, due to higher weapon strengths per shot, and this was just a first thought.
My code change would just lower the shields as if the were damaged to this strength after surprise attack (default re-sets them to 100%, even for damaged cloaked ships from my example above). Shield re-charge is not a rate, but fixed points per turn in BotF, untill shields are shot below 1.
This won't have much of an impact in BotF.
And to be fair, unlike star trek canon, in BotF surprise-attacked ships always have their shields up, unless in nebular or cloaked themselves.
I don't know how many bugs is too many but that point is reached somewhere before however many in BotF is.
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
I was assuming same TL ships, and IIRC the formulae for weapons damage (different for beams and for torps) is the same (except for Card heavy phasers and for Rom plasma torpedoes). There may be a 1 level difference due to tech reqs, ofc. I may be wrong though, but I think I used the same formulae for Supremacy.Not entirely, due to higher weapon strengths per shot, and this was just a first thought.
That's what I meant, the rate of recharge being (recharge% * max, which is a fixed amount) per round.Shield re-charge is not a rate, but fixed points per turn in BotF, untill shields are shot below 1.
Hehe.And to be fair, unlike star trek canon, in BotF surprise-attacked ships always have their shields up, unless in nebular or cloaked themselves.
- slickrcbd
- Lieutenant-Commander
- Posts: 200
- Joined: Tue Sep 08, 2015 9:22 pm
- Location: in front of a computer
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
That might work.thunderchero wrote: ↑Thu Apr 09, 2020 10:36 pm what if instead it went into normal combat, but you could not target cloaked ships?
but you could hail, evade or retreat. but I doubt AI would take advantage of this....
The main issue is that the cloaked ships are weaker than non-cloaked ships, so they need the free shot.
- thunderchero
- Site Administrator aka Fleet Admiral
- Posts: 7963
- Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2008 2:00 am
- Location: On a three month training mission, in command of the USS Valiant.
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
it is a simple code editslickrcbd wrote: ↑Sat Apr 11, 2020 2:38 pmThat might work.thunderchero wrote: ↑Thu Apr 09, 2020 10:36 pm what if instead it went into normal combat, but you could not target cloaked ships?
but you could hail, evade or retreat. but I doubt AI would take advantage of this....
The main issue is that the cloaked ships are weaker than non-cloaked ships, so they need the free shot.
at 0x071132 12 -> 5C
this bypasses the message window and starts first turn of combat before cloaked fleet can selects commands
If human player is a cloaked fleet, AI will "hold" position for first turn (cloaked free turn as normal)
If human player is not a cloaked fleet, human can select commands of hail, evade or retreat.
cloaked vs cloaked AI will always hold while human can select commands of hail, evade or retreat
this patch will give advantage to human player only, since AI will not change "hold" command.
- greenpeace
- Cadet 2nd Year
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2011 2:00 am
Re: Any modded/balanced cloak combat?
Simply increasing the effective HP of all ships results in the first shot having less of an impact. It improves the game as well since every battle isn't over in 2 turns.
I like to set all beam and torpedo damage to a 0.25 multiplier and hull and shield strength to 2x, for an 8x effective multiplier to ship HP. (I don't just multiply hull and shield by 8x since experience gain is based off of shield/hull points so that makes everyone Legendary in just a few battles.)
This also stops the Borg from destroying dozens of your uncloaked ships even if you have an overpowering fleet.
You might want to then go back and give the Romulans a 1.25x or 1.33x bonus to their (nerfed) beam and torpedo damage to make up for their weakness. The Klingons are more than fine as they are.
I like to set all beam and torpedo damage to a 0.25 multiplier and hull and shield strength to 2x, for an 8x effective multiplier to ship HP. (I don't just multiply hull and shield by 8x since experience gain is based off of shield/hull points so that makes everyone Legendary in just a few battles.)
This also stops the Borg from destroying dozens of your uncloaked ships even if you have an overpowering fleet.
You might want to then go back and give the Romulans a 1.25x or 1.33x bonus to their (nerfed) beam and torpedo damage to make up for their weakness. The Klingons are more than fine as they are.